Seton Hall Pirates vs Butler Bulldogs NCAA Basketball Betting Pick & Prediction 1/15/25
This article was published on Jan 14, 2025. Today’s picks College Basketball picks

Don’t miss out on the NCAA showdown between the Pirates and Bulldogs. The game is starting at 7:00 ET on FS1, and it’s hosted by the Bulldogs at Hinkle Fieldhouse in Indianapolis, IN. Get ready to place your bets! The over/under for this Big East conference contest is set at 138 points, with Butler being favored by -8 at home against Seton Hall.
SETON HALL PIRATES VS BUTLER BULLDOGS BETTING PICK
The Pick: Seton Hall Pirates +8
This game will be played at Hinkle Fieldhouse at 7:00 ET on Wednesday, January 15th.
WHY BET THE SETON HALL PIRATES:
- We have this one finishing with a projected score of 76-70 in favor of the Bulldogs.
- Even though we have Butler winning straight-up, we like Seton Hall at +8.
- The over/under is currently sitting at 138 points, and we like the over with a projected 146 points.
Can the Pirates Pull Off a Win at Indianapolis?
Seton Hall’s season record fell to 6-10 after a 91-85 road loss to Providence on Saturday. The Pirates entered the game as +8 underdogs but managed to cover the spread.
After a 41-41 first half, Seton Hall scored 44 points in the second half but allowed 50. The game’s total points of 176 far exceeded the over/under line of 130.5.
Seton Hall put up 85 points in their last game, shooting 44.9% from the field with an effective field goal percentage of 49.3%. They connected on 31.8% of their threes, hitting 7 of 22 attempts, while knocking down 80% of their free throws (16/20). The Pirates also grabbed 16 offensive rebounds and dished out 14 assists.
Bensley Joseph was a standout, scoring 28 points in 26 minutes, shooting 8 of 10 overall and 7 of 9 from beyond the arc. Isaiah Coleman added 26 points, hitting 3 of 5 from deep, and Prince Aligbe contributed 19 points and 7 rebounds.
Seton Hall’s defense struggled, giving up 91 points on 53% shooting from the field. They allowed 16 two-point baskets on 27 attempts, a 59% success rate for their opponents.
From beyond the arc, Seton Hall’s opponents hit 12 threes on 25 attempts, shooting 48%. They also sent them to the free-throw line 33 times, where they converted 23, shooting 69%. Seton Hall gave up 9 offensive rebounds.
Can Butler Live Up to the Hype at Home?
Butler Bulldogs Recent Game/Games
Butler dropped to 7-10 on the season after a 80-76 loss to Creighton on Saturday. The Bulldogs were +2.5 point underdogs and failed to cover the spread. The total points for the game reached 156, surpassing the O/U line of 145.5.
At halftime, the game was tied at 43-43, but Butler was outscored 37-33 in the 2nd half, leading to the loss.
Butler’s offense put up 76 points in their last game, shooting 47.6% from the field with an effective field goal percentage of 54%. They connected on 57.9% of their two-point attempts, while hitting just 32% from beyond the arc, making 8 of 25 three-point shots. At the free-throw line, they converted 8 of 12 attempts for 66.7%.
Ryan Kalkbrenner led the way with 26 points, shooting 64.7% overall and 60% from three-point range, hitting 3 of 5 attempts. Steven Ashworth contributed 22 points and 12 rebounds, though he struggled from deep, making just 1 of 8 three-point attempts. Patrick McCaffery added 21 points, shooting 42.9% from three, while Pierre Brooks II and Jamiya Neal each chipped in 14 points.
Butler’s defense struggled in their last game, giving up 80 points on 47% shooting from the field. The Bulldogs allowed their opponents to connect on 57% of their two-point attempts, with 22 makes on 38 tries.
From beyond the arc, Butler’s defense held their opponents to 32% shooting, as they hit 8 of 25 three-point shots. The free-throw line wasn’t much of a factor, with the opposing team going 8/12 for 66%. Butler also allowed 6 offensive rebounds.
