James Madison Dukes vs Marshall Thundering Herd NCAA Basketball Betting Pick & Prediction 1/9/25
This article was published on Jan 9, 2025. Today’s picks College Basketball picks

Betting on today’s Dukes and Thundering Herd game? Catch the action at Cam Henderson Center in Huntington, WV, as the Thundering Herd hosts this showdown at 7:00 ET on ESPN+. The over/under for this Sun Belt conference contest is set at 142.5 points, with Marshall being favored by -1.5 at home against James Madison.
JAMES MADISON DUKES VS MARSHALL THUNDERING HERD BETTING PICK
The Pick: Marshall Thundering Herd -1.5
This game will be played at Cam Henderson Center at 7:00 ET on Thursday, January 9th.
WHY BET THE MARSHALL THUNDERING HERD:
- We have this one finishing with a projected score of 77-69 in favor of the Thundering Herd.
- Not only will Marshall pick up the win, but look for them to cover at -1.5.
- The over/under is currently sitting at 142.5 points, and we like the over with a projected 146 points.
Will the Dukes Find a Way to Win in Huntington?
James Madison Dukes Recent Game/Games
The Dukes moved to 7-6 on the season with a 67-62 win over Arkansas State on Saturday. James Madison, a +1 underdog, not only won but also covered the spread. The total points for the game were 129, falling short of the 147.5 O/U line.
James Madison turned things around in the 2nd half, holding Arkansas State to just 23 points while scoring 34 of their own. They were down 39-33 at halftime but clamped down defensively to secure the win.
James Madison’s offense put up 67 points in their last game, shooting 40.7% from the field and 31.6% from three-point range (6/19). Their effective field goal percentage was 45.8%, and they connected on 72.2% of their free throws (13/18). The Dukes grabbed 15 offensive rebounds and dished out just 6 assists as a team.
Taryn Todd led the way with 26 points, hitting 3 of 4 from beyond the arc and shooting 52.4% overall. Xavier Brown and Elijah Hutchins-Everett both shot 58.3%, with Hutchins-Everett also making 2 of 3 from deep. Joseph Pinion added 15 points, shooting 60% from the field and 40% from three.
James Madison’s defense held their opponent to 62 points on 40% shooting from the field. They allowed 18 two-point baskets on 40 attempts, a 45% conversion rate.
From beyond the arc, the Dukes gave up 6 threes on 19 attempts, with the opponent shooting 31%. They also sent them to the free-throw line 18 times, where they hit 13 for 72%. James Madison conceded 15 offensive rebounds.
Will the Thundering Herd Live Up to Expectations at Home?
Marshall Thundering Herd Recent Game/Games
Marshall dropped to 6-8 on the season after a 58-57 home loss to Troy on Saturday. The Thundering Herd entered the game as +1.5 point underdogs and covered the spread with the narrow defeat.
Marshall led 31-19 at halftime but allowed 39 points in the 2nd half while scoring just 26. The game’s total points of 115 fell well below the 144.5 O/U line.
Marshall’s offense struggled in their last game, putting up just 57 points on 39.3% shooting from the field. Their effective field goal percentage was 42.9%, and they hit only 3 of 16 from beyond the arc, shooting 18.8% from three-point range. At the free-throw line, they connected on 10 of 17 attempts, shooting 58.8%.
Obinna Anochili-Killen was efficient, hitting 8 of 12 shots for 17 points and grabbing 9 rebounds. Tayton Conerway added 20 points, shooting 8 of 15 overall and 4 of 9 from three. The Thundering Herd grabbed 16 offensive rebounds and finished with 11 assists as a team.
Marshall’s defense held their opponent to just 58 points, with a 39% shooting performance from the field. The Thundering Herd limited them to 47% shooting on two-pointers, where they made 19 of 40 attempts.
From beyond the arc, Marshall’s defense was even more effective, as they allowed only 3 three-pointers on 16 attempts, an 18% shooting rate. They also sent their opponent to the free-throw line 17 times, where they converted 10 shots, shooting 58%.
