Cleveland Cavaliers vs Indiana Pacers Betting Pick & Prediction 5/9/25

This article was published on May 9, 2025. Today’s picks NBA picks

Cleveland Cavaliers vs Indiana Pacers Betting Pick & Prediction 5/9/25

At 7:30 ET, the 64-18 Cleveland Cavaliers (-158) will take on the 50-32 Indiana Pacers (+135) in a divisional matchup at Gainbridge Fieldhouse. ESPN will have the TV coverage for this game.

Indiana is currently on a four-game win streak and is 2nd in the Central Division. Cleveland, who has lost two straight, is 1st in the Central and favored by 3.5 points (-3.5).

CLEVELAND CAVALIERS VS INDIANA PACERS BETTING PICK

The Pick: Cleveland Cavaliers -3.5

This game will be played at Gainbridge Fieldhouse at 7:30 ET on Friday, May 9th.

WHY BET THE CLEVELAND CAVALIERS:

  • We have this one finishing with a projected score of 146-130 in favor of the Cavaliers.
  • Our projections have Donovan Mitchell finishing with 24 points, 5 rebounds and 5 assists.
  • From the field, we have the Cavaliers finishing with a field goal percentage of 48.2% and knocking down 20 threes.

Do the Cavaliers Have a Shot at a Win at Indianapolis?

The Cavaliers dropped to 64-18 on the season after a 120-119 home loss to the Pacers on Tuesday. Cleveland, favored by 5.5 points, not only lost the game but also failed to cover the spread. The total points of 239 exceeded the O/U line of 228.5 by 10.5 points.

The Cavaliers started strong, going on a 13-0 run early and leading 32-15 after the 1st quarter. However, they allowed the Pacers to chip away, giving up 35 points in the 2nd quarter. Despite a solid 3rd quarter, Cleveland’s defense faltered in the 4th, where they were outscored 36-21.

Donovan Mitchell was the standout performer for the Cavaliers in their loss to the Pacers, scoring 48 points and dishing out 9 assists. He shot 50% from the field and contributed 15 points in the 3rd quarter alone. Max Strus added 23 points, hitting 5 threes at a 41.7% rate, while Jarrett Allen was efficient inside, shooting 77.8% and finishing with 22 points and 12 rebounds.

The Cavaliers struggled from beyond the arc, making just 11 threes at a 28.2% clip, and shot 43.3% overall. Sam Merrill provided a spark with 14 points, including 9 in the 1st quarter. Mitchell also added 12 points in both the 1st and 4th quarters.

The Cavaliers’ defense shined in the 1st quarter, holding the Pacers to just 15 points, but they struggled the rest of the way, giving up 35 points in the 2nd quarter, 34 in the 3rd, and 36 in the 4th, leading to a 120-119 loss. Cleveland allowed Indiana to shoot 51% from the field.

From beyond the arc, the Cavaliers limited the Pacers to 11 made threes on 39% shooting. Cleveland sent Indiana to the free-throw line 29 times, where they made 21. The Cavaliers finished with 29 defensive rebounds, 11 steals, and 5 blocks.

Can the Pacers Hold Strong at Home?

Indiana improved to 50-32 on the season with a 120-119 win over the Cavaliers on Tuesday. The Pacers, who entered the game as +5.5 point underdogs, not only pulled off the upset but also covered the spread. The total score of 239 points went over the pre-game line of 228.5.

After falling behind 36-15 following a 13-0 run by the Cavaliers, Indiana responded by outscoring Cleveland 35-29 in the 2nd quarter. Though the Cavs edged the Pacers 37-34 in the 3rd, Indiana stormed back in the 4th, holding Cleveland to 21 points while putting up 36 of their own to complete the comeback.

Aaron Nesmith and Myles Turner each scored 23 points in the Pacers’ win over the Cavaliers, with Nesmith hitting 5 threes at a 62.5% rate. Turner added 11 points in the 2nd quarter. Tyrese Haliburton and Bennedict Mathurin contributed 19 points each, with Haliburton scoring 11 in the 4th quarter and Mathurin adding 10 in the 3rd.

Indiana shot 51.8% from the field, making 11 threes at a 39.3% clip. Nesmith connected on 5 threes, shooting 62.5% from deep. Haliburton was perfect from beyond the arc, hitting both of his attempts.

Despite giving up 119 points, the Pacers’ defense tightened up in the 4th quarter, allowing just 21 points to secure the win. They held the Cavaliers to 43% shooting from the field.

Indiana did a great job defending the three, with Cleveland making just 11 threes at a 28% clip. The Pacers also recorded 7 steals and 9 blocks.