Cincinnati Reds vs Cleveland Guardians Betting Pick & Prediction for 5/17
This article was published on May 17, 2026. Today’s picks MLB picks

The Cincinnati Reds will take on the Cleveland Guardians in an MLB regular season game. The game is set for Sunday, May 17, 2026, at Progressive Field in Cleveland, Ohio. The Reds hold a record of 24-22 and are ranked fourth in their division.
The Guardians have a slightly better record at 25-22 and are leading their division. The Reds are coming off a loss, while the Guardians have won their last game. The weather forecast for the game predicts mild conditions with light rain.
Cincinnati Reds Team Preview
The Cincinnati Reds have had a mix of outcomes in their recent games. They secured a win against the Cleveland Guardians on May 15th, with a 7-6 score. JJ Bleday was a key player with three hits and one RBI.
In their game on May 14th against the Washington Nationals, the Reds won with a strong 15-1 score. JJ Bleday stood out again, hitting two home runs and collecting six RBIs. This game showcased the Reds’ ability to generate runs with 14 hits and four home runs.
The Reds’ batting average for the season sits at .225, ranking them 24th. Despite this, they have managed to hit 60 home runs, placing them 4th in the league. Their pitcher, Brady Singer, is set to start with a 5.79 ERA and 28 strikeouts for the season.
Reds vs Guardians Game Day Info
- Sport: MLB
- Teams: Cincinnati Reds vs. Cleveland Guardians
- Venue: Progressive Field in Cleveland, OH
- Date: Sunday, May 17, 2026
- Betting Odds: Reds Moneyline +141, Guardians Moneyline -168
Cleveland Guardians Team Preview
The Cleveland Guardians are on a good streak at home. They have won four of their last five games. They scored seven runs in two of those games, showing strong offensive play.
Joey Cantillo has been a key player in the pitching lineup. He pitched six scoreless innings in a game against the Angels. His performance helped the Guardians secure a 7-2 win.
José Ramírez leads the team in home runs and runs. He has a batting average of .227 with six home runs. His on-base percentage is .353, which ranks first on the team.
BTB Betting Pick
The Guardians are favored with a moneyline of -168 against the Reds. The Reds have a weaker batting average and earned run average compared to the Guardians. Based on these stats, the pick is for the Guardians to win with a projected score of 5-3.
The total runs line is set at 8.5. The Reds’ pitching has a higher earned run average, which might allow more runs. Considering both teams’ hitting and pitching stats, the recommendation is to pick the over, with a projected total of 8 runs.