Toronto Maple Leafs vs New York Islanders Prediction & Odds – November 23, 2026

Updated

BTB Pick

New York Islanders to win Moneyline -148

Pick recorded Nov 22, 1:01 PM ET · Game time Nov 23, 7:30 PM ET

Bet New York Islanders at BetOnlineBetOnline review

Odds checked Nov 22, 1:01 PM ET. Prices vary by sportsbook, so compare before you bet.

Our NHL picks, last 30 days

  • 61–40
  • 60% win rate
  • +4.93 units

101 graded picks, updated Nov 22 Full record

18+ · Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER

Toronto visits the New York Islanders at UBS Arena with a sharper power play but a less convincing defensive record. The matchup pits the Maple Leafs’ scoring potential against New York’s stronger goals-against average.

Toronto Maple Leafs vs New York Islanders Prediction & Odds – November 23, 2026

Game details and odds

Monday, November 23, 2026 at 7:30 pm EST · UBS Arena

Team Spread (American price) Moneyline
Toronto Maple Leafs +1.5 (-185) +124
New York Islanders -1.5 (+154) -148

Total: 6.5 — over -108, under -112.

Odds checked November 22, 2026 18:01 UTC. Odds subject to change.

Toronto’s power play meets a defensive concern

Auston Matthews leads Toronto with 14 goals and 33 points, while the Maple Leafs have converted 25.7% of their power plays. That special-teams production gives them a route to offense, but their 3.52 goals against per game leaves little margin when scoring chances do not turn into goals.

Toronto’s most recent game was a 3-4 loss to Columbus, following another 3-4 loss to Los Angeles. The Maple Leafs also lost 3-6 to Chicago, 0-1 to Edmonton and 2-5 to Minnesota. They have scored three goals in each of their three most recent games without winning any of them, a reminder that offense alone has not settled the results. The Edmonton game shows a different problem: Toronto could not score at all. Against the Islanders, reversing the run will require more than repeating those three-goal outputs.

Our pick: New York Islanders to win.

Bet New York Islanders at BetOnlineBetOnline review

Islanders bring a steadier defensive profile

New York allows 2.77 goals per game and has killed 85.1% of opposing power plays, two figures that matter against Toronto’s special teams. Matthew Schaefer leads the Islanders with 26 points and 17 assists, while Simon Holmstrom has a team-high 10 goals. Their 17.2% power play offers less production than Toronto’s.

The Islanders’ most recent game was a 3-2 win over Detroit. Before that, they lost 3-4 to Winnipeg, beat Columbus 5-1, beat Anaheim 6-2 and beat Los Angeles 5-2. That stretch includes several different ways to produce: New York scored at least five in three of those wins, then won its latest game with three. The Winnipeg loss also keeps the picture from being spotless. Still, four wins in these five completed games give the Islanders a stronger recent-results case than Toronto brings into this meeting.

Injury news

Toronto Maple Leafs: Colton Sissons – Injured Reserve (Lower Body); Jack Roslovic – Day-To-Day (Upper Body); Kirill Marchenko – Injured Reserve (Lower Body); Cole McWard – Injured Reserve (Lower Body); Nick Blankenburg – Injured Reserve (Upper Body).

New York Islanders: Ryan Pulock – Day-To-Day (Lower Body); Alexander Romanov – Injured Reserve (Knee).

Availability checked November 22, 2026 18:01 UTC. Reported statuses may change; final lineups are not confirmed here.

BTB Betting Pick

Winner pick: New York Islanders.

New York’s lower goals-against average and four wins in its five most recent games make it the pick. Toronto’s productive power play and Matthews’ scoring give the Maple Leafs a credible path to an upset.

Original winner pick recorded November 22, 2026 18:01 UTC. Subsequent updates retain that selection.

More NHL picks for November 23

All NHL picks and predictions