Columbus Blue Jackets vs New York Islanders Prediction & Odds – November 17, 2026

BTB Pick

New York Islanders to win Moneyline -135

Pick recorded Nov 16, 2:01 PM ET · Game time Nov 17, 7:00 PM ET

Bet New York Islanders at BetOnlineBetOnline review

Odds checked Nov 16, 2:01 PM ET. Prices vary by sportsbook, so compare before you bet.

Our NHL picks, last 30 days

  • 39–20
  • 66% win rate
  • +8.14 units

59 graded picks, updated Nov 16 Full record

18+ · Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER

Columbus visits the New York Islanders at UBS Arena with a sharp contrast in road records: the Blue Jackets are 1-5-0 away, while the Islanders return to a building where they are 4-3-2.

Columbus Blue Jackets vs New York Islanders Prediction & Odds – November 17, 2026

Game details and odds

Tuesday, November 17, 2026 at 7:00 pm EST · UBS Arena

Team Spread (American price) Moneyline
Columbus Blue Jackets +1.5 (-230) +114
New York Islanders -1.5 (+190) -135

Total: 5.5 — over -118, under -102.

Odds checked November 16, 2026 19:01 UTC. Odds subject to change.

Columbus needs more from its attack

The Blue Jackets average 2.39 goals per game and allow 3.22, leaving little room for an off night offensively. Kent Johnson leads Columbus with eight goals and 18 points, but its 73.5 percent penalty kill could become a problem if the game turns into a special-teams contest.

Columbus arrives after losses to Philadelphia, Tampa Bay and Florida, all at home, following a 5-2 defeat in Buffalo. Those results show a team struggling at both ends: it scored only once against Tampa Bay and Florida, then conceded four against the Flyers. A 2-1 win over Dallas demonstrates that the Blue Jackets can win a tight game, but it is their only victory in the five completed games listed. To reverse the recent pattern, they need more consistent scoring without allowing opponents repeated chances to pull away.

Our pick: New York Islanders to win.

Bet New York Islanders at BetOnlineBetOnline review

Islanders bring a stronger attack home

New York averages 3.11 goals per game while allowing 2.84, a more favorable balance than Columbus carries into the matchup. The Islanders also have an 85.9 percent penalty kill, although their 17.2 percent power play has not been particularly imposing. Matthew Schaefer leads the team with 21 points.

The Islanders closed their latest trip with convincing wins, beating Anaheim 6-2 and Los Angeles 5-2 after a 3-2 loss in San Jose. Those two victories suggest their attack can respond quickly to a setback, and conceding twice in each was a welcome change from earlier defeats. Still, New York lost its two preceding home games, 5-4 to New Jersey and 5-3 to Carolina. That contrast makes the return home interesting: recent road performances favor the Islanders, but their latest results at UBS Arena leave a defensive question.

Injury news

Columbus Blue Jackets: Sean Monahan – Out (Upper Body).

New York Islanders: Logan Stanley – Day-To-Day (Lower Body); Jean-Gabriel Pageau – Day-To-Day (Lower Body); Calum Ritchie – Injured Reserve (Lower Body); Alexander Romanov – Injured Reserve (Knee).

Availability checked November 16, 2026 19:01 UTC. Reported statuses may change; final lineups are not confirmed here.

BTB Betting Pick

Winner pick: New York Islanders.

New York gets the nod because its stronger scoring and penalty killing complement two convincing recent wins. Columbus has shown it can win a close game, so the Islanders still need to avoid defensive lapses.

Original winner pick recorded November 16, 2026 19:01 UTC. Subsequent updates retain that selection.

More NHL picks for November 17

All NHL picks and predictions