Butler Bulldogs vs St. John’s Red Storm NCAAB Betting Pick & Prediction for 1/28

The Butler Bulldogs take on the #25 St. John’s Red Storm on Wednesday, January 28, 2026, at 7:00 PM ET. The game will be held at Madison Square Garden in New York, NY. This is a Big East conference game and will be broadcast on PEAC.

St. John’s enters the game as the favorite with a spread of -12.5. They have a strong record of 15-5 this season. Butler is the underdog with a spread of +12.5 and a record of 13-7. Fans can expect an exciting game as both teams look to improve their standings in the conference.

Butler Bulldogs vs St. John’s Red Storm Game Day Info

  • Sport: College Basketball
  • Teams: Butler Bulldogs vs St. John’s Red Storm
  • Venue: Madison Square Garden, New York NY
  • Date: Wednesday, January 28, 2026
  • Betting Odds: Butler Spread +12.5 (-112), St. John’s Spread -12.5 (-111), Butler MoneyLine +581, St. John’s MoneyLine -983, Over/Under 163.5

Butler Bulldogs Team Preview

The Butler Bulldogs have been strong in their recent games. They have won their last three games, including a solid 87-76 victory against Marquette. Key players like Finley Bizjack and Michael Ajayi have been crucial, with Bizjack scoring 28 points in the game against Marquette.

In the current season, the Bulldogs have an overall record of 13-7. They perform better at home with a 9-3 record, while on the road, they are even at 4-4. Offensively, they average 83.5 points per game, which ranks them 60th in the nation.

Defensively, the Bulldogs struggle with steals and blocks, ranking low in both categories. Despite this, they have managed to maintain a positive win record. Betting trends show that they have been strong against the spread, especially as underdogs, with a 4-2 record in such situations.

St. John’s Red Storm Team Preview

The St. John’s Red Storm is having a strong season with a record of 15-5. At home, they have been solid, posting a 10-3 record. In their conference, the Big East, they hold an AP Rank of #25, showing their competitive edge.

Offensively, the Red Storm averages 85.0 points per game, ranking 38th nationally. They are effective at drawing fouls and converting free throws, with 19.7 made per game, which ranks 15th. Their shooting from the field is consistent, with a field goal percentage of 46.4.

The team has excelled recently, winning their last three games. Notable players include Bryce Hopkins and Zuby Ejiofor, who consistently contribute to scoring and rebounding. Their strong play has helped the Red Storm maintain a perfect record when favored to win.

BTB Betting Pick

For the spread pick, consider taking Butler at +12.5. Butler scores 83.5 points per game, while St. John’s scores 85.0 points. The spread suggests a large gap, but Butler’s ability to score and rebound makes it likely they keep the game closer than 12.5 points. With Butler’s solid performance in scoring and rebounding, they might cover the spread.

For the over/under pick, consider the under at 163.5. Butler and St. John’s average 168.5 points combined per game. However, both teams have average field goal percentages and may not hit their scoring averages. The high total may not be reached, making the under a reasonable choice.