Indiana Pacers vs Cleveland Cavaliers Betting Pick & Prediction 5/6/25
This article was published on May 6, 2025. Today’s picks NBA picks

At 7:00 ET, the Pacers will travel to Cleveland to take on the Cavaliers. Indiana comes into this game with a 50-32 record and is currently on a three-game winning streak. The Pacers are 9-point underdogs and have a moneyline of +314.
On the other side, the Cavaliers are 64-18 and are favored by 9 points. Cleveland is ranked first in the Eastern Conference and has a moneyline of -399. The over/under line for this game is set at 229.5.
INDIANA PACERS VS CLEVELAND CAVALIERS BETTING PICK
The Pick: Cleveland Cavaliers -9
This game will be played at Rocket Arena at 7:00 ET on Tuesday, May 6th.
WHY BET THE CLEVELAND CAVALIERS:
- We have this one finishing with a projected score of 146-129 in favor of the Cavaliers.
- Our projections have Donovan Mitchell finishing with 23 points, 5 rebounds and 5 assists.
- From the field, we have the Cavaliers finishing with a field goal percentage of 48.6% and knocking down 20 threes.
Will the Pacers Pull Through as the Away Underdog?
With a 121-112 win over the Cavaliers on Sunday, the Pacers improved to 50-32 for the season. Indiana, who entered the game as +8.5 point underdogs, not only won but covered the spread. The game’s total score of 233 points narrowly exceeded the O/U line of 229.
Indiana took control early with a 10-0 run, turning a 28-25 deficit into a 35-28 lead. Although Cleveland fought back in the 2nd and 3rd quarters, outscoring the Pacers 65-56, Indiana clamped down in the 4th, holding the Cavs to 22 points while scoring 29 of their own.
Andrew Nembhard’s 23 points and 5 threes at 83.3% shooting led the Pacers to a win over the Cavaliers, with Tyrese Haliburton adding 22 points and 13 assists. Aaron Nesmith contributed 17 points, hitting 4 threes at 66.7%.
Indiana connected on 19 threes, shooting 52.8% from beyond the arc and 53% overall. Nembhard scored 8 points in the 4th quarter, while Haliburton added 9, and Nesmith put up 11 in the 3rd.
Despite giving up 33 points in the 2nd quarter, the Pacers tightened up defensively in the 4th, allowing just 22 points to help secure the win. They held the Cavaliers to 112 points on 45% shooting.
Indiana did an excellent job defending the three, limiting Cleveland to just 9 made threes on 23% shooting. The Pacers also recorded 9 blocks and 6 steals in the game.
Can the Cavaliers Grab a Win at Home?
After a 121-112 loss to the Pacers on Sunday, the Cavaliers’ record now stands at 64-18. Cleveland was favored by 8.5 points at home but failed to cover the spread. The game’s total of 233 points went over the pre-game line of 229.
Indiana’s 10-0 run early on set the tone, but Cleveland fought back, winning the 2nd and 3rd quarters. However, with the Cavs trailing just 92-90 going into the 4th, the Pacers pulled away by outscoring them 29-22 in the final period.
In their loss to the Pacers, the Cavaliers struggled from beyond the arc, hitting just 9 threes at a 23.7% clip. Overall, they shot 45.9% from the field.
Donovan Mitchell led the way with 33 points, including 12 in the 3rd quarter. Ty Jerome added 21, with 8 coming in the 4th, and Evan Mobley contributed 20 points and 10 rebounds, shooting 69.2% from the field.
The Cavaliers struggled defensively against the Pacers, allowing 121 points on 53% shooting in their loss. Cleveland gave up 36 points in the 1st quarter but managed to hold Indiana to 28 points in both the 2nd and 3rd quarters. The Pacers added 29 points in the 4th.
From beyond the arc, the Cavaliers allowed Indiana to hit 19 threes at a 52% clip. The Pacers also went 14/15 from the free-throw line. Cleveland finished with 30 defensive rebounds, gave up 7 offensive boards, and recorded 8 steals.
